I would recommend buttercream over this, as it is a bit stronger and delicious smelling. This wasn't bad, and my 4 year old daughter was excited to smell cookies haha. Maybe if this was combined with something else for a scent fusion? I'd still recommend it, just not my 1st choice, but nice none-the-less.
February 22, 2014
Too sweet for me
Cookies, just cookies. Too strong and sweet for me! I can only smell the cookies.
January 7, 2014
Is mine a dud?
I love cookie scents so I was really excited to melt this tart. Unfortunately, I've had the tart melting for several hours and have hardly been able to smell it. I hope this one is a dud, because I really want my house to smell like Christmas cookies!
December 15, 2013
The first tea light I lit for this lasted about 4 hours, and it smelled great. I noticed a strong scent of vanilla and butter cookies. The second time I lit it, I smelled a strong odor of burning plastic which I assume is the base wax that gives it the structure, and just a hint of the good cookie scent. I'm not having luck with any of the holiday scents I've tried so far because they only last two or three tea lights, unlike my go-to year round floral favorites which I usually get at least 6 lightings each. Storm Watch is the longest lasting one I've found so far.
December 14, 2013
Great little wax melt
I love the smell of this wax melt and could not believe a small melt like this could smell go good. My daughter came home and wanted to know what I was baking, thinking I was baking cookies, but I told her I was actually burning the wax melt that smelled just like cookies baking in the oven. Great scent.
November 25, 2013
Strong Butter-Cookie Scent!
Christmas Cookie is one of my all time favorite Yankee scents. The throw is AMAZING - melt one tart in the kitchen and the whole house smells like we have fresh baked, real butter cookies. You really can't tell the difference between this tart melting and someone baking butter cookies! It really sets the mood for the holiday season.
November 11, 2013
A bit strong
I bought these & WHOA a bit strong, I'm mixing them with my buttercream & seems to tone down the smell, smells good alone just way too strong for me,
November 9, 2013
Our very favorite!
We buy this one again and again! It's our favorite. While it is called Christmas Cookie, it can be used all year round.
November 4, 2013